About Us

Our background

Coast 2 Coast Cards started over 30 years ago when our father got us involved in buying baseball card collections in the NY/NJ tristate area.  We are two brothers, Mike & Brian, that immediately developed a passion for collecting all cards from our first early on purchases. We have since become the premier buyer's of all sports and non-sport related cards in the country.  The reason for this is the integrity we bring when evaluating the value of an individuals collection along with our combined deep knowledge of the cards we purchase.  

We differentiate ourselves from others in this industry by guaranteeing the highest paid prices (ALWAYS IN CASH).  No deal is too small or large for us to handle.  Over the last 10 year's alone we have spent over $10 MILLION in cash.  

When its time to sell, collectors are left with limited options.  Most local card dealers may be interested in buying your collection but often times what they're willing to pay is just a small fraction of the actual value of your cards.  The process of selling your collection is quite simple.  We will first appraise what you have and show you the exact value of your cards.  We will then together determine a price that works for both parties.  Typically we pay approximately 80% of the overall value of the collection.  No one in the country comes close to this!  

Looking to buy:

All Sports & Non-Sports Cards (1900-1979)

Complete Sets

Star & Rookie Cards

All Unopened Material


Magic the Gathering & Pokemon

Please call us for your free appraisal and to set-up an in person meeting to evaluate your card collection

Upcoming Buying Trips In Your Area

Month of April

Buying in NY/NJ Area

Event Details

Month of April

Buying in NY/NJ Area

We will be in the NY/NJ Tristate are buying all sports card collections.  Call now to reserve a specific time to meet.  We can come to you t...

Event Details

Contact Us

Send Message